Skip to content
Skip to content

Which SEO figures can you quote with their source limits?

Quote each research figure with its original unit, base and comparison. This ledger keeps usable wording beside source locations, without upgrading its design.

Observed answers on stated dates, not a ranking. The usable number is often less sweeping than the familiar headline. A source may establish a historical answer length, an experimental visibility score or a dated vendor-naming rate. Those are useful observations when their labels remain intact.

This ledger provides wording that can travel with a figure. It does not upgrade a paper's design or convert a reported association into an intervention effect. You can follow the source location to the original and use the linked data tables to inspect our descriptive reanalyses.

Rovira and colleagues called their proposed explanation for a change in scholarly search ordering “only an inference.” That short qualification belongs beside the result, not on a page the reader is unlikely to open. Rovira et al., 2019, §4.

Download this ledger as CSV. Its rows preserve the wording, source location, unit and unavailable uncertainty rather than inventing counts from rounded source percentages. The October 30 original CSV is retained as a historical file; its GEO row was withdrawn on November 3, 2026. Use the dated current ledger above.

Which external findings can you quote?

Finding Wording suitable for quotation Location and limit
Observable optimization signals in a Google result sample Lewandowski et al.'s 2021 paper classified 59.0% of 256,853 Google result URLs as definitely optimized, 29.0% as probably optimized and 12.0% in its combined negative group. Figure 1, PDF p. 6, printed p. 17. Selected German-language query sample, not all Google results; classifications do not identify a causal optimization effect. Rounded shares do not supply recoverable integer numerators or count-based intervals.
Wikipedia result positions Among the paper's 1,974 Wikipedia results, 27% appeared at position 1 and 79.3% in the top ten. Lewandowski et al., §5, PDF p. 7, printed p. 18. The denominator is Wikipedia results. Do not describe this as Wikipedia's share of all first positions. Rounded shares; exact position counts and intervals are not reconstructed.
Scholarly relevance ordering Rovira et al. report Google Scholar median-rank correlations of 0.968 and 0.721 for unrestricted one-term and two-term searches, and 0.990 and 0.994 with title restriction. The one-term title-restricted workbook omits two query columns: using all 25 gives 0.991 after rounding rather than the reported 0.990. 2019, Table 2, reprint PDF p. 56. Correlation across position-wise median summaries from selected scholarly searches, not AI-answer citation probability. Coefficients are not proportions.
A temporary observed Web of Science ordering The study reports a citation-like Web of Science ordering during 20 to 25 May 2019; Table 2 gives 0.907 for that collection and −0.075 for the other collection. Rovira et al., Table 2 and §4. Operator testing is the authors' inference. The historical observation does not establish the present system's behavior.
Historical voice-answer length Backlinko's 2018 study of 10,000 Google Home results reported an average spoken-answer length of 29 words. Original study, answer-length section. Vendor study, historical system and selected sample. This is answer length, not query length or a universal content target; distribution-level uncertainty is unavailable.
GEO experiment, fragile evidence GEO experiment: Aggarwal et al. (KDD 2024) headline a gain of up to 40% in a position-adjusted word-count visibility metric. Treat it as fragile: the ICLR 2024 draft reported 37%, the paper's own five-seed rerun (appendix Table 6) gives 36.9%, and on Perplexity adding citations cut the judged score by 23% (19.0 vs 24.7) while keyword stuffing raised it 14%. It is not a citation, traffic or conversion gain. KDD 2024, Tables 1, 6 and 7; the 1,000-query supplied-source test split and separate 200-example Perplexity experiment use different outcomes. See the unverified-numbers ledger for the withdrawn row and version limit.

We have not recovered the exact ICLR submission for an independent check of the reported 37% headline. That version comparison remains a reported historical claim, not a newly verified result. The KDD paper uses a 1,000-query supplied-source test split and a separate 200-example Perplexity experiment. These are metric comparisons, not count-based citation probabilities. The former 41% and 28% row is preserved in the unverified-numbers ledger as a withdrawn interpretation. It is no longer an approved effectiveness quotation.

How often do repeated answers disagree?

The following rates count complete vendor-question-engine groups. A group is mixed if the vendor was named in some, but not all, of its three valid target repeats. All intervals are descriptive 95% Wilson intervals; dependent observations prevent treating them as independent population trials.

Engine Mixed / eligible complete groups Rate and interval
ChatGPT 159 / 2,860 5.6% (4.8% to 6.5%)
Claude 253 / 2,860 8.8% (7.9% to 9.9%)
Perplexity 200 / 2,860 7.0% (6.1% to 8.0%)
Google AI Overviews 302 / 2,752 11.0% (9.9% to 12.2%)
Google AI Mode 345 / 2,860 12.1% (10.9% to 13.3%)
Combined 1,259 / 14,192 8.9% (8.4% to 9.4%)

Primary: September release DOI 10.5281/zenodo.22907695, engine_presence counts. Reanalysis dated 30 October 2026. CSV with category breakdowns. The 108 incomplete Google AI Overviews groups are omitted from this complete-repeat measure. Uniform absence counts as agreement, so the statistic is not an engine-quality score.

Which vendors illustrate low measured presence?

Observation in release 2026-09 Count / valid target answers Percentage and descriptive 95% Wilson interval
Microsoft Dynamics 365 named for CRM 36 / 150 24.0% (17.9% to 31.4%)
Oracle OPERA Cloud named for hotel property management 25 / 149 16.8% (11.6% to 23.6%)
GE HealthCare named for radiology and medical imaging 24 / 150 16.0% (11.0% to 22.7%)

Source: the same deposit, relevant category's vendor mention_rate fields. Full checked-vendor CSV. Naming can include multiple vendors per answer. These figures describe the fixed questions and engines; they measure neither product quality nor commercial market share.

Does being named mean the vendor’s own site was cited?

The September publisher aggregates contain 8,085 named vendor-answer pairs, of which 2,608 carry a qualifying own-domain citation: 32.3%, descriptive 95% Wilson interval 31.2% to 33.3%. A pair combines one checked vendor and one eligible answer. Multiple pairs can arise from the same answer. Derived counts and category table.

These are summaries of the deposited publisher aggregates. The qualifying-name dictionary is not included in that deposit, so this table is not an independent reproduction of the individual citation verdicts. It does not mean that every remaining pair lacked a source of any kind; an answer can cite a third party.

How should you choose a number to quote?

Use the row whose outcome matches your sentence. A naming figure cannot support a statement about source ownership. A historical search-position figure cannot establish the behavior of every AI engine. A study's proposed mechanism should remain labelled as an explanation or inference unless the design tested it directly.

If you shorten a sentence, retain the unit before removing a qualification. The base often matters more than an extra decimal place. Our unverified-number ledger records examples where a plausible-looking number changed meaning in retelling, including objections we withdrew after reading the original.

The unresolved question is which future observations will remain comparable. The dated tables above are usable now; their presence here does not promise that a later release will produce the same counts.

What our own data shows

Supports: The repeated-question table records 1,259 mixed-naming groups among 14,192 complete vendor-question-engine groups, 8.9% (Wilson 95% interval 8.4% to 9.4%). Mixed means named in one or two of three valid repeats. This is a conditional description of the September archive. Download the complete repeat table, vendor-presence table and naming/citation aggregate table. All derive from release 2026-09. Counts and units appear above; Wilson intervals describe observed proportions without an independence claim. This ledger contains no Study 1 result.

Does not support: Future rankings or a causal publishing effect.

Suggests: Follow-up within the stated setting.

Sources

  • Broadcastwell (2026). The Absence Index, release 2026-09: observed naming of B2B software vendors in AI answers. Broadcastwell LLC. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22907695. All releases: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22150321. CC BY 4.0.

  • Lewandowski, D., Sünkler, S., & Yagci, N. (2021). The influence of search engine optimization on Google's results: A multi-dimensional approach for detecting SEO. In WebSci '21 (pp. 12 to 20). ACM. doi:10.1145/3447535.3462479 . Accessible original Verified 30 October 2026.

  • Rovira, C., Codina, L., Guerrero-Solé, F., & Lopezosa, C. (2019). Ranking by relevance and citation counts, a comparative study: Google Scholar, Microsoft Academic, WoS and Scopus. Future Internet, 11(9), 202. doi:10.3390/fi11090202 . Accessible original Verified 30 October 2026.
  • Dean, B. (2018, February 28). We analyzed 10,000 Google Home results. Here's what we learned about voice search SEO. Backlinko. https://backlinko.com/voice-search-seo-study Verified 30 October 2026.
  • Aggarwal, P., Murahari, V., Rajpurohit, T., Kalyan, A., Narasimhan, K., & Deshpande, A. (2024). GEO: Generative engine optimization. KDD 2024. doi:10.1145/3637528.3671900 . Accessible original . Author manuscript v3: https://arxiv.org/html/2311.09735v3 Verified 30 October 2026.
  • Broadcastwell. (2026). Absence Index, release 2026-09 [Data set]. Zenodo. Release JSON, answer JSONL and README. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22907695 Verified 30 October 2026.

  • Rovira, C., Codina, L., Guerrero-Solé, F., & Lopezosa, C. (2019). Ranking by relevance and citation counts: Source workbooks [Data set]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3381151 . Google Scholar one-term title-restricted workbook, Full1 B2:B1001 and C:AA. Verified 30 October 2026.

Report publication status

OSF preprint: not pursued.

Email research@broadcastwell.com.

Cite this page

Report DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23804758. All versions: 10.5281/zenodo.23804757.

Broadcastwell research team. (2026, October 30). Quotable numbers, with their original boundaries. Broadcastwell. https://docs.broadcastwell.com/research/evidence/quotable-numbers/ Published 30 October 2026; updated November 4, 2026.

@online{broadcastwell2026research46,
  author = {{Broadcastwell research team}},
  title = {Quotable numbers, with their original boundaries},
  year = {2026},
  date = {2026-10-30},
  url = {https://docs.broadcastwell.com/research/evidence/quotable-numbers/},
  urldate = {2026-10-30},
  note = {Published 2026-10-30; updated 2026-11-04}
}

Prepared by the Broadcastwell research team. Lead: Vikram Patel.

Sources checked 30 October 2026. This page has not been peer reviewed.

Last updated: 2026-11-04. Next review: 2027-02-02.

Continue