What evidence should an AI factual-accuracy alert include?
Broadcastwell measures and fixes whether AI search engines name B2B software companies.
Run the free checkAn accuracy alert should connect the observed claim to the dated source that contradicts it, with the question, product scope and review state retained. The Absence Index’s Procore statement record retains Claude’s 22 September 2026 assertion: “there is no pricing page on their website.” It links the vendor’s pricing page, read on 8 October 2026, as contradictory evidence and keeps the question needed to inspect the flag. The record labels the assertion wrong and leaves team review in progress.
Observed answers on stated dates, not a ranking.
What we measured
Measured. Wrong About You provides the classification example for an alert record. Its method assessed 2,922 statements about 70 vendors in answers captured on 22 and 23 September 2026, comparing them with vendor pages read on 8 October. It labeled 1,924 true, 113 wrong, five stale and 880 unverifiable. The checkable base was 2,042, including 118 wrong-or-stale statements. Dental practice software accounted for 17 wrong-or-stale statements among 162 checkable statements; legal practice software for 34 among 183. These are dated statement classifications, not monitoring-tool extraction scores. Team review remains in progress. These classes describe reviewed answer claims; they do not measure an alerting product's detection coverage, false alarms or speed. A notification needs its own retained evidence before a reader can assess it.
One retained answer
In one retained answer record, Google AI Overviews responded to “best construction management software for a small residential builder” on 22 September 2026, run 2, with the fragment “custom quote”. The fragment concerns JobTread. Its published classification record labels the custom-quote claim wrong against the pricing reference read on 8 October 2026, with team review in progress. This historical answer wording is not current pricing or independent verification of the product claim.
What this means for you
Reasoned. Request a sample alert before choosing a monitoring arrangement. It should carry the answer's capture date and engine, the exact disputed claim, the cited URL and the dated primary evidence used to assess it. The record also needs a reason for the classification and a clear place to note a correction or unresolved question.
Use the three study labels as a worked routing example. A wrong claim needs evidence of contradiction. A stale claim needs the historical statement and the source showing the later state. An unverifiable claim needs the missing evidence identified; it must not be treated as demonstrated falsehood. The study does not measure any alerting product's ability to detect those cases.
Ask how the supplier distinguishes an observed answer from its own inference about risk. The alert may identify a factual concern without establishing customer harm, lost revenue or a legal violation. If someone has already corrected a source, the record should show that delivery state separately from whether a later answer has changed.
Choose an alert format that a product owner can assess without a second round of detective work. A notification that gives only a score and a vendor name does not provide enough evidence to settle the claim.
- If you buy monitoring: ask for one complete alert record and check its source trail.
- If you own the product fact: confirm the right classification before approving corrective wording.
- If you report to a client: distinguish the observed issue, its review state and any delivered correction.
A tracker may reproduce an engine’s incorrect statement exactly, so extraction agreement does not establish product-fact accuracy. Conversely, a correct fact does not establish company matching or denominator calculations. An alert sample should expose the complete answer, extracted field, alias match, calculation and dated primary passage. Retain all 880 unverifiable statements as unresolved rather than silently converting them to errors or confirmations. The Study 6 record and product-quality distinction explain those separate checks.
Also asked as
What evidence should an AI factual-accuracy alert include?
How accurate are GEO tools across different industries?
Related
- Wrong About You's classifications
- The source evidence standard
- Vendor facts and scope
- Compare agency evidence
- The Manual on a reproducible evidence record
- More buying answers
Next step
Free 10-question check (one engine). No email is needed; runs are limited per network and per day, and by the site's daily allowance.
Claiming or correcting a vendor record is free and never depends on a purchase.
Our answer-study method, v1.1.
Answer Repair: $490.
Prepared by the Broadcastwell team.
Page owner: Priya Nair, Management Consultant. Corrections: hello@broadcastwell.com
Related evidence
- How should an answer page link each claim to evidence?
- Construction software category record
- Absence Index method and data definitions
Published . Last updated .